Starring: Emily Watson, Robert Carlyle, and Pauline McLynn
Directed by Alan Parker
Year: 1999
IMDB / Wikipedia
In the words of John Lennon, “If you had the luck of the Irish, you’d be sorry and wish you were dead.”
For all of the pagentry and the lore of the Irish, actually being Irish stunk for a long time. You were hated and invaded by the English, most of your heroes are criminals and, if you wanted to come to America, you had a hell of a time finding everything from a place to sleep to employment because of the prejudice. Irish were stereotyped as being lazy, shiftless, drunkards who would earn a days wages and then spend a week drinking them away. Sadly, as with many stereotypes, this has an air of truth to it.
To be poor and Irish was the theme of Frank McCourt‘s best-selling memoir, Angela’s Ashes, upon which the film was made. The story is of his early life living in squalor with his family, first in America and then in Limerick, Ireland. The tale shows how life is hard when there’s little money to go around, depression setting on the western world, not enough food or shelter to keep you satisfied, and watching small children succumb to their conditions. Frank watched several siblings die at the hands of starvation and unclean living environments, watched himself starve night after night because there wasn’t enough food for everyone, watched his mother beg the Church for anything she could, and his father piss away most of their money with his alcoholism. It’s tough to watch because it is so real.
I read the book years ago and much of it stuck with me. Most of my gripes with the movie were not about how different it was from the source, but about the things it left out. Frank’s life was not all sorrow and misfortune and the film misses a lot of that. There are parts where he and his family seem happy, but those moments are glazed over, trumped by some other greater tragedy, or completely omitted. But, watching it again, I see that in doing it like this, the film keeps with the spirit of the book better than a casual viewer may think.
The theme of the book and the film was that life is hard but, through those hardships and how you deal with them, is how character is developed. Though not an original theme, it is one that is very tragic because it’s a true story. But, casual viewers of the film don’t realize is that, to get to the better parts you have to go beyond the story. Both the book and film end with Frank going to America to find his dream of happiness and the second book ‘Tis, which will probably never be made into a film, expands upon that with much more humor than the first. So, to watch this film or read the book and find all the humor is gone is accurate because, as Frank so illustrates, the situation and his life were not condusive to such at the time. That’s what makes it a great story.
But it’s a sad story. I do not recommend watching this if you are in a great mood as it will bring you down or in a bad mood as it might lead you to suicide. If anything, view this as something that will make your troubles seem trivial and your life that much sweeter.
Most Valuable Actor: There were three actors that portray Frank: one at age 5, one at 10, and another at 15. Michael Legge plays the oldest Frank and did a great job with a very emotionally-charged portrayal of Frank as he comes to grips with the feelings he has kept pent up inside himself and as he tries to find his way to happiness and salvation.
Trailer: