Starring Derek Luke, Denzel Washington, and Joy Bryant
Directed by Denzel Washington
Year: 2003
IMDB / Wikipedia
Normally, I’m in the mood for a movie like this–a heartwarming story of overcoming adversity and stifling personal demons to move on with your life–but I couldn’t get full invested in this film. The story centers on Antwone Fisher (Luke), a hot-headed navy seaman who, after a fight with another crew member, is told to see the base psychologist (Washington) for an evaluation. The two of them forge a bond of trust and of understanding as they both dive deep into the issues that has brought Antwone to this stage in his life.
On the surface, this is a good movie. The story itself is well-structured (by the real-life Antwone Fisher himself) and well-directed (by Washington in his debut) and the acting is just fine. However, there’s something a bit off about the story. The characters, though based on real people, are not very well-developed and that’s sad considering there’s only a handful worth giving a damn about. The tales of abuse are horrifying and all-too real but the use of the flashback constantly was a bit disconcerting though it was the only way to efficiently tell the story.
Thinking about it, my issue is with the dialogue. I have noted before how sometimes dialogue doesn’t seem realistic because no one speaks in soliloquies and everything is too well-thought out to be natural. The same can be said for this screenplay. For a person and a character that was brutally honest about himself and his situation, the end result is something that is too artificial and too over-filled with emotion to make a widespread emotional connection to the viewing audience.
If you do watch this film, do so at face value as it will give you the best return for your time.
Most Valuable Actor: Derek Luke’s portrayal of Antwone Fisher was superb, giving a lot of pain and conflict to the role that seemed about as genuine as anything ever captured on celluloid. If only he had better dialogue with which to work.
Trailer: